Morality Play Case Fetal Rights And The Fetus As Person

MSA #2: Mariah Neuhauser Morality Play Case: Fetal Rights and the Fetus as Person: The Case of J.D.S. In terms of the utilitarian moral theory, utilitarian moral theory considers human actions as being morally good if the end result or effect of the action is good regardless of whether or not the â€Å"means† of getting to the respective end result or effect of an action was good. In terms of the deontological moral theory, deontological moral theory considers human actions as being morally good if the some part of the action is morally good regardless of whether the effect or end result of the action is good. Question 1: â€Å"If a fetus is considered a â€Å"person,† does it follow that the fetus has the full range of â€Å"rights† to which an already-born person is entitled? (What makes any person entitled to rights?)† (Pierce 41). Mill: If the government decides to infringe upon a person’s right to happiness (in this case, it could be having a child or not having a child), then it does not matter whether a fetus is a person or not or whether abortion is viewed as moral or immoral. If the fetus will have a debilitating disease or the mother will not be happy with having a child, then abortion should be a legal option to make either the fetus or the mother happy. If the fetus is a person, then the fetus also has a right to happiness, but it is arguable about when that right to happiness begins. I would argue that the mother’s right to happiness overrules a fetus’s right to happiness becauseShow MoreRelatedJohnson Controls : A Voluntary Fetal Protection Policy890 Words   |  4 Pagesexposure to lead, can cause harm to a fetus† (DeGeorge 61). It is for this reason that Johnson Controls, as well as other manufacturers of lead based products, â€Å"hired no women in battery-productions facilities before the passage of the 1964 Civil Rights Act† (Cornell 72). Johnson Controls production jobs paid very well and were desired by both men and women. After Johnson Controls began hiring women for these production positions they implemented a voluntary fetal protection policy in 1977. This policyRead MoreThe Theory Of Utilitarianism By John Stuart Mill2034 Words   |  9 PagesMill also argued that, â€Å"Actions are right in proportion as they tend to promote happiness, wrong in proportion as they tend to produce the reverse of happiness† (pg. 5). Each individual rate happiness in accordance to what its definition is or their interpretation of happiness. Globally, â€Å"happiness† can be defined as pleasure in the absence of pain. What brings about happiness and pleasure for any one person may not be the same for another individual. In the case of someone who uses illicit drugsRead MoreAbortion in the United States Essay1748 Words   |  7 PagesAbortion has been a controversial topic for many years. Some people favor adoption and some are against it. â€Å"In 2008 an estimated 1.21 million abortions were performed in the Unites States.†(Jones, and Kooistra). Many opinions collaborate in abortions rights or abortion legislation. â€Å"In 2008, 84,610 women obtained abortions in Texas, producing a rate of 16.5 abortions per 1,000 women of reproductive age. Some of these women were from other states, and some Texas residents had abortions in other statesRead MoreEthical Implications of Abortion2898 Words   |  12 Pageswould argue that every woman should have the right to terminate a pregnancy for whatever reason, because her body and the fetus are one entity. Since termination of a pregnancy or abor tion is the status quo within society, most would agree with this consensus. I, however, without properly acknowledging the rights of all the parties involved with abortion (the fetus and father), I do not believe it should be used so freely within society. Since the historic case of Roe v. Wade in 1973, abortion has beenRead MoreDebate Over The Issue Of Abortion2043 Words   |  9 Pagesacross the country as the issue is so complex, there are a variety of views and responses to its morality and legality. To understand the current debate over the issues concerning abortion we must not look at this issue from a black and white perspective of what is right and what is wrong , but rather we must take a comprehensive approach which analyzes the complex questions and factors tied to the morality of abortion. By looking at the responses to the question of abortion, as discussed by MaryRead MoreThe Ethical Concept Of Genetic Engineering1157 Words   |  5 Pagesassignment will discuss the ethical concept of genetic engineering and how it demonstrates its relevance to midwifery professional practice and maternity care. Before analysing genetic engineering and looking at the arguments as to whether it is ethically right, an understanding o f what the terms and lawful procedures mean should be determined. In order to construct this assignment, multiple resources were accessed. These resources included analysing books, both hard copies and electronically. Books areRead MoreThe Fetal Position: A Pro-Life Argument Essay2142 Words   |  9 Pagesthe termination of the fetus, or abortion in other terms. Mathematically, that is estimated to be 1.2 million babies that have no hope for a future outside the womb (American Pregnancy). Everyone has a right to life; this right is exercised in many parts of the American life, namely the Declaration of Independence (The Abortion Controversy 113-116). Therefore, the United States’ federal government should go to greater lengths to prohibit these so called ‘abortions’ in every case, regardless of the situationRead MorePermitting Abortion and Prohibiting Prenatal Harm Essay2987 Words   |  12 Pageswomans rights. Id like to elucidate that contradiction and examine three solutions which rise out of current literature; Id like the n to propose a somewhat new, fourth solution. The Contradiction Stated in terms of personhood, the contradiction is this: abortion is permitted or condoned because the fetus (2) is not a person, but prenatal harm is prohibited or condemned because the fetus is a person. (3) Obviously one cant have it both ways — either the fetus is or is not a person. StatedRead MoreWhy Pro Choice Is The Right Choice1879 Words   |  8 PagesNational Issues Paper Why Pro-Choice is the Right Choice Abortion is a hot topic in United States politics as of late, and rightly so. Though religion, costs, maternal psychological damage, and societal morality are often cited as reasons to oppose abortion, a woman’s right to make her own decisions should always prevail. Abortion should be nationally legalized during the first trimester of pregnancy because Roe V. Wade has declared abortion a â€Å"fundamental right† to women, fetuses are incapable of feelingRead MoreDr. Meserow Is A Mentally Competent Woman2587 Words   |  11 Pagesrecognize that Doe is a mentally competent woman carrying her first child, and the fetus is currently around 35 weeks. It also important to recognize that Dr. Meserow is a board-certified obstetrician/gynecologist. Dr. Meserow informs both Doe and her husband of the diagnosis and highly recommends either an immediate cesarean section or to induce labor in order to prevent any further potential damage to the fetus due to the lack of oxygen from the compromised placenta. Doe refuses both of the recommendations